Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.

If you select links we provide, we may receive compensation.

My work also allows me to compare popular products to ones Ive used for years.

a collage featuring the Elevation Whey Portein Blend and the Garden of Life Whey Protein powder, both in the flavor chocolate

Photo:Courtesy of Brand

The average person only needsabout 0.8 to 1.2 grams of proteinper kilogram of body weight.

However, since building muscle is one of my goals, I strive to hit 100 grams daily.

Like most nutrients, youre better off getting protein fromwhole food sources like chicken, eggs and lentils.

Elevation by Millville Chocolate Protein Powder

PHOTO: Amazon

Here’s what I ultimately thought.

The tradeoff is that it also contains more fat and sugar.

Why is that important?

Garden of Life SPORT Grass-Fed Whey

PHOTO: Amazon

I blended both with almond milk in my shaker bottle, shaking each for 30 seconds.

When it comes to easy mixing, Garden of Life was the clear winner.

However, the sweeteners in each are what differentiates the two.

Garden of Life SPORT Grass Fed Whey Protein Powder

EatingWell / Katie Tuttle

The Elevation whey protein powder is sweetened with sucralose, while Garden of Life uses organic stevia extract.

However, if you prefer a natural sweetener, Elevations use of sucralose may be a turnoff.

The Bottom Line

Choosing between these two protein powders wasn’t easy.

Elevation by Millville Chocolate Protein Powder in a measuring cup

EatingWell / Katie Tuttle

However, if I’m taking something on a near-daily basis, taste and value are significant considerations.

Therefore, theElevation by Millville Chocolate Protein Powder(view at Amazon) remains my favorite.

She has been powerlifting for six years and testing food and kitchen products for two.

Elevation by Millville Chocolate Protein Powder

EatingWell / Katie Tuttle

Three protein shake bottles on a kitchen counter

Klean Athlete Klean Isolate Protein Powder on yellow table next to prepared drink and spilled powder

A selection of the best collagen powders displayed on a counter

a container of protein powder with a scoop coming out

a collage featuring some of the vegan protein powders

Best Greens Powders tout

A selection of magnesium supplements we tried

A selection of fiber supplements we tested

A selection of creatine supplements we tested

apple cider vinegars lined up on countertop

Best vitamin C supplements primary photo

Three Electrolyte powders on countertop

The 9 best vitamin D supplements—from liquid to gummies to capsule pills

A selection of matcha powders we tested

a young woman taking a supplement with a glass of water

Different Colostrum Supplements being displayed